God’s ivory – the disconnect between devotion and slaughter
By Jamie Joseph
Halfway through my interview with world renowned documentary photographer, Brent Stirton, I lean in and tell him that I think I have a line to the Dalai Lama.
“Jamie, don’t go there!” he says, cutting me off. “This is all about diplomacy. The public needs to be winning over China’s Buddhist leaders and religious heads of authority.”
Stirton’s response seals my suspicions; asking the Dalai Lama to make a public stand against ivory will only anger the Chinese Government. Their citizens are by far the biggest consumers of ivory, and so it is China we have to win over.
Brent Stirton has done it harder so that we can walk further. For more than 9 months of the year he traverses the continents, investigating critical global issues, and unveiling the interwoven fabric of societies through his profound visual interpretations. Working alongside investigative reporter Bryan Christy, they exposed the booming ivory trade in Buddhist and Catholic religious objects in the 2012 National Geographic cover story, Blood Ivory.
But far too little has been said about the role of religion since this story hit the headlines. Most ivory objects are religious objects, with extraordinary sculptures fetching six figure price tags – but clearly there is a disconnect between the craft and where the ivory comes from. Every day nearly 100 elephants are brutally killed in Africa, their bodies riddled with bullet holes, and their faces butchered with axes until the tusks are yanked out.
I was raised Catholic, but have followed Buddhism most of my adult life. People buying ivory have a right to know that their purchase is causing incredible trauma. Elephants are highly intelligent beings, and they have long term supportive bonds between family members, so it’s not just a species facing extinction, its massive individual suffering.
“Journalism is failing in communicating these issues,” says Stirton. “Religion is a major player in the poaching crisis. We’ve ignored it, we’ve accorded religion too much respect in this regard, and we’ve placed devotion above slaughter.”
Many people still believe that ivory comes from elephants that die a natural death. Only a very small percentage of Chinese people buy ivory, but with such a large population, that small percentage has devastating effects.
“In China, owning ivory is a status symbol that is considered a good investment,” adds Stirton. “But it is also recognition of faith, and a religious totem that acknowledges their success.”
Illegal ivory is flooding into China, and using legal pathways as cover. So why does the Chinese government, on one hand support environmental debate, and on the other hand they still refuse to shut down the carving factories?
“China’s carving factories aren’t going anywhere,” says Stirton. “China now has enormous presence in Africa, they need the assets that Africa has, and the vast majority of African governments are happy to have them there. This comes before the environment.”
But if China cares so much about business in Africa, then surely the African leaders have the advantage, and they can put pressure on China to shut down the ivory carving factories?
“These are not democracies,” Stirton bluntly replies, adding, “There is just too much corruption, and poverty continues to be an exploitable phenomenon. The key to law enforcement is to affect the demand.”
Brent Stirton has witnessed some of the most unprecedented elephant killings in Africa. Back in 2012 Stirton covered one of the largest mass elephant slaughters in decades, when, armed with grenades and AK-47s, poachers entered Bouba Ndjidah National Park in Cameroon, and gunned down more than 600 elephants over a three month period. They even killed the babies.
That same year Stirton also took first prize at the World Press Photo Awards for his assignment, Rhino Wars, which included documenting the work of the IAPF rangers based in Zimbabwe and South Africa. I tell Stirton that we’re currently trying to source ‘military leftovers’ for the rangers, and I will return to my African homeland in October, joining the IAPF rangers on the frontline, and writing ‘stories from the trenches’. The objective of that mission is to showcase the brave work of the rangers, and inspire people everywhere to take action in their own country.
“We need to support the rangers any way we can,” says Stirton. “I’ve just returned from the Congo where my friend, Virunga Park Director Emmanuel de Merode, was ambushed and shot several times back in April. It’s the middle of a war zone, and they’re trying to save animals.”
Suspects of the attempted assassination on Prince de Merode include the FDLR – a group of guerrillas who have been living in the park since 1996 – as well as charcoal traders and people associated with a British oil company attempting to illegally explore for oil in the national park.
In other parts of the world, and on a smaller scale, the demand for ivory religious objects by devout Catholics, in places that include the Philippines and The Vatican, is also fuelling this vile trade.
“The Vatican did eventually respond to the Blood Ivory story,” says Stirton. “They changed their policy on ivory, and they issued public statements. A couple Filipino priests implicated in the smuggling of ivory were also excommunicated from the Church, so they did react.”
But the issue was quickly swept away, and now with Pope Francis at the helm – a spiritual leader frequently linked with defending the environment – it is in his power to lead the charge and encourage The Church’s 1.2 billion members to become defenders of elephants.
Last year Elizabeth Chitwood, founder of Elephantopia, collected nearly 12 000 signatures through an online petition, calling for the world’s largest religion to take a prominent stand for the world’s largest mammal. She called, emailed and mailed a hard copy to the Vatican, but they never did respond.
“It would be good if people continued to put pressure on The Church,” adds Stirton, “People always prioritize what is happening to humans, but they fail to see how these things relate to each other.”
Elephants are a keystone species, and so it’s not only elephant families being destroyed, but vital ecosystems humans depend on. We’re heading towards the sixth extinction, and if we cannot save the big things, if we cannot save our majestic elephants, then how are we ever going to save the small things?
The illegal ivory trade is funding transnational crime syndicates and environmental terrorism, yet mainstream news is asleep at the wheel – and so it is up to every one of us to be a driving force for change. We can and we must do more.
Read: Blood Ivory, National Geographic, Oct 2012.
By Bryan Christy. Photographs by Brent Stirton.